Landlords are threatening to take City of York Council to the High Court over its plans to introduce additional licensing for smaller HMOs.

York Residential Landlords Association claims plans to extend the current scheme to include all smaller HMOs with less than five occupants in areas of the city where there are high levels of shared housing, are unlawful and irrational.

Leading property lawyer David Smith (pictured) of for legal firm JMW has written to the council on behalf of the York group explaining that its members are deeply concerned.

They claim it is unlikely to meet the requirements of a lawful consultation, that the accompanying documents fail to make a clearly evidenced case for the scheme to be rolled out, and that parts of the proposed scheme are unlawful.

Smith tells LandlordZONE: “The evidence to support the licensing process is very poor and shows very little correlation between HMO density and the issues of noise, anti-social behaviour and rubbish.

“In fact, there is no evidence which links those issues to rental property at all and the council itself seems to suggest that it may be more closely linked to the normal night and business life of the city centre.”

He adds that if the authority tries to proceed on the basis of this current flawed evidence base and consultation then it’s likely York landlords will have a strong case to say that this is unlawful.

The council’s legal team is currently considering the letter. In its consultation document, it says York has about 2,000 HMOs occupied by less than five occupants and adds: “We know from experience that there will be a small, and probably vocal, minority of landlords who will never see the overall value of additional licensing of HMOs. They take an essentially narrow, self-interested view.”

The consultation at ends on 27th June.


  1. Guaranteed House Sale
    We Buy Any House – Guaranteed House Sale for market value

    Our customer-friendly service means we can make you a guaranteed house sale with cash offer for any house.

    Our team of professionals knows your local property market and makes you the best and most realistic offer as soon as we have the details.

    We can start immediately, without waiting for a valuation of the property, by offering an indicative (but still guaranteed) cash-in-hand offer.

    Once you accept our offer we will purchase your property within the specified time and at the stated cost. There are no hidden fees.

    Expect our professionals to visit your property for a full evaluation before setting a proposed time schedule. This way you know exactly what is going on.

    The entire process of selling your house is transparent. The usual business processes, as well as our own unique procedures, will be explained whenever you ask.

    Our satisfaction only comes when you are satisfied.

    We always give you our contact details so you are always able to find out what is happening. Phone us, e-mail us or use the contact form on our website.

    We take the stress out and assure a Guaranteed house sale
    St. James Investments will buy, flats, houses, land or commercial premises such as offices and shops and we base our offer on current market trends. Our dedicated, trained consultants will visit you personally to view your property and we then give you the time to consider and accept our offer. You can use our recommended, professional solicitors or appoint your own trusted firm but, either way, we still pay all the fees.

    Our clients choose St James Investments to take the stress out of their quick & guaranteed house sale, whether they’re moving abroad, relocating or going through a divorce, they want to avoid repossession, solve debt problems, or just to eliminate the endless viewings, long chains and high charges involved with estate agents. We provide a free survey and valuation as part of our service, to cut your costs even further.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here