We rely on private landlords to provide homes for millions of people. We expect them to invest their own money, maintain those properties, comply with increasingly demanding legislation and provide tenants with greater security. At the same time, many landlords tell me they feel increasingly uncertain about the future of the sector and their place within it. A healthy rental market depends on landlords and tenants working together. Yet the conversation around renting increasingly feels polarised, with debate often framed as though one side's interests can only be protected at the expense of the other.
I have spent three decades dealing with landlord and tenant disputes, and I have seen first hand the damage caused when either side fails to meet their responsibilities. I fully support giving tenants greater security, strengthening their rights and holding rogue landlords to account. However, I worry that somewhere along the way, we have started treating landlords and tenants as though they are on opposite sides.
Tenants are encouraged to understand and exercise their rights, while many landlords tell me they feel increasingly powerless, worried about making mistakes and uncertain about what happens if a tenancy goes wrong. That is not a healthy starting point for any relationship.
A good landlord is worth keeping
Think about the landlords who maintain their properties properly, respond to repairs, keep rents reasonable and want their tenants to stay for years. These are precisely the landlords we should want in the market. Even the most professional and responsible landlords are facing rising costs and increasing regulatory responsibilities. Higher mortgage payments, insurance, maintenance, compliance and, from April 2027, another increase in tax on their property income.
Meanwhile, the Renters' Rights Act restricts rent increases to once a year, with tenants able to challenge proposed increases through a tribunal. Those protections serve an important purpose, but they do not make the costs of providing rental housing disappear. While protections around rent increases play an important role, they do not remove the financial realities of managing and maintaining rental property. Of course, landlords must accept that property investment carries risks. However, there is a tipping point where the potential returns simply are not worth it.
At Landlord Action, around three in ten of the possession cases we are handling involve landlords seeking to sell. That does not necessarily mean every property will leave the rental market, but it does indicate how many landlords are reconsidering their position.
Why profitability still matters
Landlords are repeatedly told they must operate professionally, meet higher standards and treat their properties as businesses, all of which I agree with. However, if we are going to expect landlords to run professional businesses, surely we have to recognise that the investment needs to remain financially viable? Many landlords have benefited from long-term property value growth. However, day to day viability remains important. Properties still need to be financed, maintained and improved, often against a backdrop of rising costs and changing regulatory requirements.
Nobody is suggesting landlords should have a free pass to charge whatever they like or make money at their tenants' expense. They have legal responsibilities, and providing someone's home comes with obligations that go well beyond an ordinary commercial transaction. They are also investing substantial amounts of their own money, taking financial risks, maintaining properties and providing a service that millions of people rely on. What is the incentive to do all of that if the best you can hope for is to cover your costs and perhaps make a little money from capital appreciation in 20 years' time? That is assuming property values rise and you can afford to hold on for that long.
Profits are never guaranteed, of course. However, we should not be surprised when people reconsider whether to invest if the potential returns no longer justify the risks.
Are we creating a culture of mistrust?
There is another consequence of all this that I do not think we are talking about enough. Landlords are feeling increasingly squeezed financially and worried about getting things wrong under the new legislation. At the same time, tenants are understandably more aware of their rights and what they should expect from their landlords. There is nothing wrong with that, but I worry that the increasingly confrontational debate around renting is creating suspicion on both sides.
In all my years working in this sector, I have seen growing frustration directed at landlords in some parts of the housing debate, alongside increasing concerns from tenants about affordability, standards and security. It sometimes feels as though landlords and tenants are being encouraged to see each other as enemies, rather than two parties who need to work together. Many of the proposed reforms are intended to address genuine concerns around housing quality, affordability and tenant security. These are important objectives. The challenge is making sure those improvements strengthen the sector without discouraging responsible landlords from remaining part of it.
The reality is that property is fundamentally a people business. Most landlords want a reliable tenant who pays their rent and looks after the property. Most tenants want a landlord who maintains their home, treats them fairly and leaves them to get on with their lives. Landlords also have a responsibility to demonstrate their professionalism, not just through complying with legislation, but through how they manage their properties, communicate and build relationships with their tenants. Trust and mutual respect are essential.
At Landlord Action, we see what happens when tenancies go wrong. Believe me, eviction is not something most landlords want. It is stressful, expensive and time-consuming. It is the end of the line most hope never to face. Ultimately, a successful tenancy is one where both sides understand their responsibilities, trust each other and can get on with their lives.
Finding the right balance
We seem to have reached a point where landlords are expected to absorb rising costs, accept greater risks and keep providing homes, while being made to feel increasingly unwelcome. The Government cannot rely so heavily on private landlords to house millions of people while continuing to introduce measures that make providing those homes less attractive. Responsible landlords need to feel valued, supported and confident that they can make a reasonable return. Tenants need security, fair treatment and somewhere decent to live. These should not be competing objectives.
We need to stop treating every improvement in tenants' rights as though it must come at the expense of landlords and start recognising that a healthy rental market depends on both. The long-term success of the private rented sector depends on attracting and retaining responsible landlords while giving tenants confidence in the homes they rent. Those goals are not in conflict. In fact, the sector works best when both are achieved together.








.avif)
.avif)
%20(800%20x%20450%20px).avif)







.avif)



Comments